Heritage Foundation and Fox News via Stand With Arizona Blog ^
| 05-06-2013 | John Hill
America's financial future? Destroyed by mass amnesty for 20+ million
illegal aliens.Mexico's Oligarchs say "Gracias, Gringo!"
-
by John Hill
Stand
With Arizona
The widely-anticipated Heritage Foundation estimate on the cost of the 'Gang
of Eight' illegal alien amnesty bill was released
this morning, and it is a unmitigated disaster.
The 'comprehensive immigration' overhaul being taken up in the Senate this
week would add at least $6.3 trillion to the national debt if 11 million
illegal aliens are granted legal status, according to the conservative
think tank. And that amount assumes the low-ball figure of "11 million" - which
most serious experts say is a gross underestimate.
The cost would arise from illegal aliens tapping into the government's vast
network of benefits and services, many of which are currently unavailable to
them. This includes everything from standard benefits like Social
Security and Medicare to dozens of welfare programs ranging from housing
assistance to food stamps.
"No matter how you slice it, amnesty will add a tremendous amount of pressure
on America's already strained public purse," Robert Rector, the Heritage scholar
who prepared the report, said in a statement.
"There's no way you can look at this and say that it's good for the
American taxpayer," Heritage Foundation President Jim DeMint
said.
This study should be a deal-breaker for any Republicans who were even
flirting with supporting it, as it would absolutely devastate U.S.
taxpayers - who are already paying $113 billion per year for the costs
of illegal aliens.
In the course of their lifetime, the report estimates that each
amnestied illegal alien would receive on average $592,000 MORE
in government benefits than they would pay in taxes.
The $6.3 trillion figure is based on what illegal aliens would cost the
government over the course of their lifetime. It factors in the expected $3.1
trillion in taxes they'd pay to the government.
Remarkably, Heritage claims its $6.3 trillion is a "conservative
estimate". Annd of course since it uses the absurd "11 million"
baseline figure for the number of illegals, the actual amount of debt
amnestied illegal would add may be more than double the Heritage
estimate. Far more credible estimates peg the actual number of illegals
between 20 and 30 million.
You can read the full Heritage Foundation report here.
Supporters of immigration amnesty have been skeptical of efforts to assign a
cost to the immigration bill. Proponents argue that the value of bringing
millions of illegal immigrants out of the shadows and presumably into the
taxpaying workforce is immeasurable.
Stephen Moore, an economist and Wall Street Journal writer, said
that despite the Heritage findings, there are other studies showing the
legalization will be an economic boon that could grow the economy -- in turn
alleviating the country's deficit problem.
Sen. Marco Rubio, (R-FL), a key co-author of the legislation, repeated his
claim that illegal aliens applying for legal status would not have access to
federal benefits while they are applying. After obtaining a green card, they
would still be ineligible for many federal benefits for five years, said Rubio.
But Rubio is ignoring what Sen.
Jeff Sessions (R-AL) revealed last week - that given lax state rules for
illegal and government benefits - millions of illegals would begin to
receive benefits immediately. That's because State laws often provide
benefits for anyone “lawfully present.” And thus many illegal aliens granted
legal standing, known as registered provisional immigrant status, could
immediately become eligible for public benefits.
And of course Rubio and his gangmembers completely ignore the simple fact
that, due to the current misinterpretation
of the 14th Amendment, when an illegal has anchor babies - children
border on U.S. soil - they instantly qualify for food stamps, WIC,
Medicaid and other benefits on their children's behalf.
"Those who claim that amnesty will not create a large fiscal burden are
simply in a state of denial concerning the underlying redistributional nature of
government policy in the 21st century," the Heritage report said.
ACTION ALERT: IMMEDIATELY FORWARD THIS REPORT TO YOUR
SENATOR. Tell them in addition to the other numerous reasons to
oppose mass amnesty for 20+ million illegal aliens, the Heritage "conservative
estimate" of an added $6.3 TRILLION to our already skyrocketing debt is
insanity.
DEMAND THEY OPPOSE THE 'GANG OF EIGHT' BILL!
Find Your Rep's Contact info
HERE.
DIOGENES invites you to pull up a chair on this fine day and read posts from around the world. The writing may lean to the right...but that's the way Diogenes wants it! You may leave your opinion, but Diogenes rarely changes his! WELCOME!
-
The Dems went down to Georgia They was looking for a seat to steal They were in a bind, 'cause they were way behind They were willing t...
-
Today Dispatch ^ Oops! Apparently, the state of Rhode Island had 150,000 people incorrectly placed on their voter rolls and nobody not...